Skip to main content

The Road to Excellence

The concept of deliberate training has been in the news quite a bit over the last decade. Even more recently with the publication of Anders Ericcson's new book Peak.

I am reading Peak now and will write more about it over the next week.

All the way back in 1996 Ericcson edited a book entitled The Road to Excellence that explored how to achieve excellent performance in a myriad of domains.

I first read this book after seeing an article about deliberate training in the mid-2000s.

There are two chapters in particular that are helpful to coaches.  The first chapter "The Acquisition of Expert Performance" is by Ericcson himself, the other is Chapter 3 "Deliberate Practice in Sports: What is it?" is by multiple authors.

 Some notes:

To look at expertise as a researcher, and not as a coach or practitioner, you need to find evidence that can be replicated, not just rely on anecdotes. This makes it hard in sports since excellence basically requires that we continuously get to a smaller and smaller pool. Only so many can keep winning.
Therefore, the key is "to search for patterns of development across exceptional individuals."

A few patterns from the research of Bloom (1985)

Future elite athletes start sports as play. Their interest grows and they show promise. Parents find an instructor. Parents provide "enthusiastic support and encouragement" at this stage. With improvement better instructor sought and more training time.  (Stage 1)

During early or midteens the elite performers committed to their sport--included "a master teacher and optimal training conditions." (Stage 2)

"Across many different domains, Bloom found that nearly all international-level performers had worked with coaches or teachers that had either themselves reached international level of performance or had instructed other students who had attained that level." (p20) (Stage 3)

The final stage for elite performers--they mastered what teachers taught and started to look for"their own innovative contribution to domain."
    My thoughts:

    Also, in the first 3 stages the future elite performer taxes the family financially and time-wise so much so that there is often only one elite performer per family.  I had not considered the limiting factor of this.

    Also, looking at the first stage notice that the role of the parent is supportive, enthusiastic and that the teacher does not need to be a master. Participation is described as play and the athlete does not yet specialize.

    Even when people have similar amounts of training there are large differences in achievement. Ericcson goes further stating that "experience is a weak predictor of performance. "Why?

    Training methods--and, here we get to the components of deliberate training:
    1.   Well defined task
    2.   Appropriate level of difficulty (think Flow--don't want to be bored or frustrated/anxious)
    3.   Informative feedback 
    4.   Repetition
    5.   Correction of errors
    6.   Not necessarily fun
    7.   Requires tremendous focus and concentration
    If you think about it most of us rarely do deliberate training--we just play or practice, and we are often missing these components

    The training can be on your own, but you must return to the teacher for evaluation of where you are and correction. In fact, it would be impossible to excel without additional training beyond practice time and doing this consistently.  

    An interesting point he makes is that you must continue to train diligently and consistently to maintain your skills when you are already accomplished.

    Another key finding--master teachers/researchers think concentration is key in deliberate training.  Focus in training determines the quality of your performance.
    "Master teachers argue that full concentration is essential and that when it wains the musician should rest, because practice without full concentration may actually impair rather than improve performance." (p24)
    He continues with good detailed information about the importance and quality of rest in creating concentration.

    Coaches and expert performers consider "desire to succeed" the most important factor for eventual success in a domain. (Think Grit by Duckworth. The capacity to hold that goal and train for something over an extended period of time. Best part of each of these theories is that they all start to intersect making it impossible to say that any one is the singular answer. Instead as you read them all you start to see how it fits together with how you teach and who you teach)

    The best are willing to sacrifice time and enjoyment to train deliberately in order to reach excellence. They enjoy leisure and social more, but are willing to do what is required.

    Training trumps talent, but much research left to be done at the time of this book.

    Another aside, I want to also note that there has been a renewed discussion about the 10,000 hour rule (associated with Ericcson's research) and its legitimacy.  This Business Insider article is a good example of the criticism aimed at the research. It's important to note that the idea of the 10,000 hours was really amplified by Malcolm Gladwell in his book Outlier and was not central to the original research.  Ericcson addresses the issue himself in the Finding Mastery Podcast which you can find here.

    (Disclosure:  This little blog is an amazon affiliate. If you purchase a book or anything through here the blog makes a small percentage. Thank you in advance.)


    Popular posts from this blog

    Why Start This Blog...

    I enjoy reading and read quite a few books and articles on a weekly basis.

    As a result I end up in quite a few conversations about books.  People ask me for recommendations and recommend books to me often.

    Sometimes I get emails from people I don't know asking me for book lists. Sometimes this request comes from friends.

    So, I thought I would keep a simple blog of books, some with notes, some with reviews, some with great quotes, and some just in list form in order to keep the conversation going.

    I am hopeful people will recommend more books to me.

    I'll write more about each later, but here are my three favorite books from 2016:
    The Art of Learning

    The Inner Game of Tennis

    What I Learned Losing a Million Dollars

    (This is my hobby, but it does take some time.  Disclosure: This little blog is an amazon affiliate. If you purchase a book or anything through here the blog makes a small percentage. Thank you in advance.)

    The Inner Game of Tennis

    "As soon as he tries to exercise control he loses it."--Tim Gallwey.
    Back when I coached at Northwestern one of my students recommended a book to  me, Zen in the Art of Archery

    Man, what a hard book.  Here let me give you an example,

    "This exquisite state of unconcerned immersion in oneself is not, unfortunately, of long duration. It is liable to be disturbed from inside. As though sprung from nowhere, moods, feelings, desires, worries and even thoughts incontinently rise up, in a meaningless jumble.... The only successful way of rendering this disturbance inoperative is to keep on breathing quietly and unconcernedly, to enter into friendly relations with whatever appears on the scene, to accustom oneself to it, to look at it equably and at last grow weary of looking.”

    At least it was very hard for me at the time. I was not ready. As a result I stayed away from other books that I thought might be similar, like The Inner Game of Tennis.

    Then I read a great intervi…

    The Art of Learning

    I loved The Art of Learning by Josh Waitzkin. I listened to it on Audible while driving across the country so I don't have my notes as readily available as I might otherwise.

    I am buying the book so that I can "read" it again, but until then here are a few thoughts:

    Waitzkin, who was the basis for the movie Searching for Bobby Fisher, tells an entertaining story of his journey from young chess master to martial arts champion as an adult. He's still a relatively young adult (mid-thirties) so I assume there will be many more journeys of mastery in his life time.

    He asserts in the book that his greatest gift is not playing chess or martial arts (both of which he mastered) but, but rather his great strength lies in knowing how to learn. He explains his approach in The Art of Learning.

    If you want to be a great learner then commit to the long term process of learning even if you need to stumble, fail and deal with a little humility.

    He was very good at dealing with failu…